To fix this problem, you can do the following:
- Open your web application's solution in Visual Studio 2013
- In Solution Explorer, click on your web application's project so that it's highlighted
- Hit the F4 key to open the Project Properties menu
- Modify your settings appropriately similar to what you did in IIS Manager when you deployed your web application to your Production environment (i.e. Windows Authentication -> Disabled and, perhaps, Anonymous Authentication -> Enabled)
- Save your changes and hit the F5 key to place the application in debug mode again
At this point, running your web application in debug mode will now execute in similar fashion to what you configured on your production web server for your web application.